Beyond the Sale: A Jewelry Store in Maitland, FL You Trust

In Maitland, FL, finding a trusted jeweler is about more than just buying a necklace or engagement ring. It’s about building a lasting relationship with a jewelry store in Maitland, FL, that puts your needs first. Whether you're shopping for a milestone gift or seeking expert jewelry repairs, Reynolds & Co. Jewelers delivers honest service with a personal touch.

Call us today at 407-645-2278 and experience the difference yourself. Need a repair, appraisal, or something custom? Contact us today to get started.

A Local Legacy of Trust

Reynolds & Co. Jewelers has served the Maitland community for decades. This jewelry store in Maitland, FL, isn’t part of a chain—it’s a locally owned business built on personal relationships and craftsmanship. Customers come back year after year because they know they'll get fair prices and honest advice.

When you step into our store, you’re welcomed like family. Our staff listens to your needs and helps you find or create something perfect—no pressure, just guidance. That’s why so many people in the area refer to us as the most trusted gold jewelry store in Maitland, FL.

Full-Service Jewelry Care Under One Roof

Jewelry is often tied to life’s most meaningful moments. At Reynolds & Co., we believe in protecting that value. We’re more than a retailer—we’re a full-service jewelry store in Maitland, FL, offering comprehensive care for all your pieces.

Services we offer include

• Jewelry Repair: From broken chains to prong tightening, we restore your items with care.
• Custom Design: Turn your ideas into reality with our design team. We craft everything from scratch using quality materials.
• Appraisals: Get certified valuations for insurance or estate purposes.
• Cleaning and Inspection: Keep your jewelry looking its best with our regular maintenance services.



Each service is handled with precision and respect for the value—emotional and monetary—your piece holds.

Custom Jewelry That Tells Your Story

No two stories are the same, and your jewelry should reflect that. Our team works with you one-on-one to design personalized pieces that fit your style and budget.

Whether it’s a reimagined heirloom or a brand-new engagement ring, Reynolds & Co. has earned a reputation as the jewelry store in Maitland, FL, where creativity meets craftsmanship.

We also specialize in gold. As a premier gold jewelry store in Maitland, FL, we offer custom pieces that range from sleek and modern to timeless and traditional.

Repair and Restore What Matters Most

Broken jewelry doesn’t have to mean broken memories. Our repair team handles everything from minor fixes to full restorations. We treat each item as if it were our own—carefully and respectfully.

That’s part of what makes us a standout jewelry store in Maitland, FL. Whether it’s a clasp, missing stone, or a ring that no longer fits, we’ll make it right again.

Even if your gold jewelry has seen better days, bring it in. As a reliable gold jewelry store in Maitland, FL, we understand how to restore its beauty without compromising its integrity.

Appraisals You Can Count On

If you’ve inherited a collection or need insurance coverage, you need accurate appraisals from a team you can trust. We provide certified jewelry appraisals done in-house.

Every appraisal includes documentation and photos, giving you peace of mind. It’s one more reason why locals turn to Reynolds & Co. as their trusted jewelry store in Maitland, FL.

Why Locals Choose Reynolds & Co.

We know Maitland. We know jewelry. And we know our customers. People continue to choose us because:

• We treat you like a friend, not a transaction.
• Our pricing is transparent—no gimmicks.
• We offer both traditional and modern designs.
• Our staff includes experienced gemologists and artisans.

When you want a jewelry store in Maitland, FL, that genuinely cares, look no further.

A Gold Standard for Gold Jewelry

Reynolds & Co. isn’t just any jewelry shop—we’re also recognized as a top-tier gold jewelry store in Maitland, FL. From classic chains and earrings to ornate gold rings, we carry a curated selection you won’t find in big-box stores.

Looking for something specific? We’ll help you custom-design it. Every gold piece we sell is crafted to last and made to shine.

Visit Us Today—Let’s Create Something Meaningful

Whether you're buying, repairing, or designing something one-of-a-kind, trust Reynolds & Co. Jewelers to guide you through it. We’re proud to be the jewelry store in Maitland, FL, where lasting relationships are just as important as lasting jewelry.

Call 407-645-2278 now or visit our contact page to get started and experience the Reynolds & Co. Jewelers difference—where trust goes beyond the sale.