Engagement Rings

Engagement Rings

Being in Winter Park so long, we are a must stop for anyone looking for a one of a kind engagement ring. We have decades of experience in helping people get the right ring and making sure it's ready for their big day. We have a certified gemologist here to ensure you get the quality stone or mounting that you want as well as making sure it's sized and fits perfectly.

Starting with The Stone

At Reynolds & Company Jewelers we know that there are times you want to start with a special gem or diamond and design a piece of jewelry around it or mount it in a piece you already own. Our designers can help you pick that perfect setting and help your vision of that special ring come to life.



No matter what you are looking for we either have it in the store or can get it for you usually within 24 hours.

Preset Rings

What makes us stand out is our one of a kind pieces. With all the "box stores" it becomes frustrating when you drive around and keep seeing the same rings and designs repeatedly. Here at Reynolds & Co. we pride ourselves in carrying a wide variety of engagement rings and wedding bands to choose from. We try to find unique settings to provide our customers optimal choices.

Wedding Bands

Congratulations! Now you have a wedding to plan and you have to find a ring for him as well as one that fits against your engagement ring nicely. Being right here on Park Avenue in Winter Park keeps us in the loop of what men and women want as fashion evolves. We carry everything from classic bands to diamond bands made in platinum, 14-18kt white and yellow gold to more contemporary bands such as titanium or steel for men. 

Share by: